Decision 2
My decision
Show how far each KPI is from its target, not just its total.
- Chose
- Progress from the KPI’s baseline to its target, from 0 to 100%, the same way for every KPI. One colour per circle, so the gatekeeper can compare circles on one screen.
- Rejected
- The first dashboard screens: a card with the raw value for each KPI, a monthly trend, and a yearly target only for donations.
- Because
- The data scientist’s analysis showed the KPIs share no unit: francs, percentages, counts, a score from −100 to 100. Some succeed when they go down, like involuntary headcount change. Raw totals can’t be compared or added up; progress can.
First screens · raw values
Private donationsCHF128’400
Net promoter score34
Involuntary headcount change1.2%
On track? Ahead of last year??
Final · progress to target
Private donations61%
CHF 0CHF 1.6 m
Net promoter score58%
2044
Involuntary headcount changelower is better80%
3.5%0%
Same three KPIs. On the left you need to know each one’s target by heart. On the right, every bar reads the same way, whatever the unit or the direction. Demo values; baselines and targets as the team defined them for the prototype.